Italian World Heritage sites and tourism growth: no faster increase after listing

Italian World Heritage sites and tourism growth: no faster increase after listing
Contents
  1. The 30-second summary
  2. What you will find here
  3. The 344 results that do not agree
  4. The sixteen Italian cases
  5. How large are the effects that are found
  6. Why it works in some places and not others
  7. The consequence no one questions
  8. What to do with this, in practice
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. What we do not know
  11. References

Securing UNESCO recognition is almost always justified through a tourism lens. This is the rationale that sways municipal authorities, shapes bid dossiers, and rationalizes the expenses tied to the application. The econometric studies attempting to quantify this impact have spent two decades generating contradictory findings, prompting the meta-analysis reviewing them to frame the issue as plainly as possible: panacea or placebo?

The answer, based on what the available data can sustain, proves uncomfortable for both sides. The effect exists and it is small: evidence from a panel covering the twenty-seven European Union member states estimates a 0.22% increase in visitor numbers for each additional site, whereas hotel capacity accounts for triple that impact. In already saturated destinations the net effect is close to zero, and looking at the Italian case on a municipality-by-municipality basis, growth rates during the five years following inscription did not exceed those recorded in the five years prior.

And there is one randomised trial, the sole one within this domain, whose outcome deserves attention prior to drafting a nomination: declaring a location a World Heritage Site boosts visitation intent, yet no more so than designating it a national park does.

The 30-second summary

What follows are effect estimates, not visitor counts. It is worth reading in each row which population and which period were measured, because that is where almost all the variation lives.

FindingResultStudy and year
Size of the evidence base344 econometric estimates across 43 distinct papersYang, Xue and Jones, ATR (2019)
Sixteen Italian sites, before and after the listingSubsequent expansion remained comparable to previous trendsRibaudo and Figini, JTR (2017)
Added value of the label over «national park»Statistically negligible within domestic marketsVolgger and Taplin, JST (2022)
Effect per additional site across the EU-27+0.22% tourist arrivals; hotel capacity rose by 0.66%Kutlu and others, Sustainability (2024)
Effect in Chinese cities on national holidaysInflow intensity increased by between +6.7% and +10%Gao and others, CIT (2022)
Effect in saturated destinationsNet impact hovers near zero: functioning as a placebo brandHạnh and others (2026)
Having a site against having anotherPossessing one proves significant, whereas possessing another yields marginal benefitsYamarik, Tourism Economics (2025)
Effect of the earliest Spanish inscriptionsMore pronounced for 1980s inscriptionsCastillo-Manzano and others, JCH (2021)
Canadian case with a concrete figure+6.2% visitors: translating to 3,000 annually and $200,000VanBlarcom and Kayahan, JHT (2011)
Effect on international tourism in ChinaFound to be negligible concerning both arrivals and revenuesZhang, Cheng and Zhang, TE (2023)

What you will find here

• What the meta-analysis of 344 estimates found and which six factors explain why the results disagree.

• The Italian research contrasting the preceding five-year span against the subsequent five years, analyzed municipality by municipality.

• The field’s only randomised experiment and why its result deflates the argument for the label.

• The figures from the studies that do find an effect, and how large they actually are.

  • Why the label works in some places and not others: development, saturation, heritage type and age.

• The effect nobody disputes and which has nothing to do with visitor numbers.

The 344 results that do not agree

The obligatory starting point is the meta-analysis by Yang Yang, Lan Xue and Thomas Jones, published in Annals of Tourism Research in 2019. Their diagnosis of the situation is explicit: UNESCO’s World Heritage inscription is considered to positively influence tourism demand, but the relevant econometric research has yielded inconsistent results.

To resolve that they synthesised the effects of World Heritage Site status across 344 econometric estimates from 43 studies. And rather than report a mean figure — which would be misleading — they identified what explains the dispersion.

The six variables identified as significant by the meta-regression constitute the study’s core contribution in their own right: the research period, the level of development in the destination country, the heritage type, the dyadic data type, the measure of site endowment and the use of robust standard errors.

Note the final point. The fact that employing robust standard errors accounts for a share of the effect size serves as a methodological caution rather than a substantive discovery: it implies that certain inflated published impacts stem from model specifications failing to properly adjust for data dependency. Furthermore, the sub-group breakdown highlights distinct drivers across developing and developed nations, as well as between cultural and natural heritage domains.

Understanding «panacea or placebo»

The meta-analysis title picks up a phrase coined a year earlier. Bailey Adie, C. Michael Hall and Girish Prayag published in Journal of Sustainable Tourism in 2018 a comparative analysis of three sites under the concept of a «placebo brand»: a label that produces the effect managers expect of it because they believe it produces it, not because it moves visitors.

The latest systematic review within this domain, conducted by Mai Thi Hạnh along with co-authors in Multidisciplinary Reviews in 2026 — a low-quartile journal whose findings ought to be evaluated with appropriate caution — analyzed 53 papers spanning five databases from 2000 through 2025, ultimately delivering the most transparent synthesis currently accessible: World Heritage status is not a universal magic bullet that automatically generates tourism growth.

Their geographical breakdown is the most decision-useful part: in developing countries, the designation functions as a quality signal, increasing tourist flows by approximately 6.7% to 10% during peak holiday periods. In saturated destinations, by contrast, the average net impact is close to zero, effectively rendering the label a placebo brand.

StudyWhat it measuredWhat it foundWhat it cannot establish
Yang, Xue and Jones, ATR (2019)344 estimates from 43 studiesSix factors explain the dispersionYields no single interpretable mean effect
Ribaudo and Figini, JTR (2017)16 Italian sites at municipal levelNo evidence of accelerating growthA mature destination; not generalisable to emerging countries
Volgger and Taplin, JST (2022)Randomised experiment on visit intentionThe label adds nothing over national park statusMeasures stated intention, not actual visits
Kutlu and others, Sustainability (2024)EU-27 panel, Driscoll-Kraay method+0.22% per additional siteNational aggregate; does not locate the effect
Gao and others, CIT (2022)Mobility big data between Chinese city pairs+6.7% to +10% on national holidaysTwo holidays a year; does not cover the rest of the calendar
Zhang, Cheng and Zhang, TE (2023)287 Chinese cities, matching and differencesPositive domestically, null internationallyDoes not explain the contrast between the two markets

The sixteen Italian cases

The study that most undermines the tourism argument is by Giorgio Ribaudo and Paolo Figini in Journal of Travel Research in 2017, and its virtue lies in the scale of analysis. In contrast to previous literature, the article focuses on the smallest statistical unit, the municipality, to examine the site’s impact on the destination.

That matters a great deal. An effect diluted across a province or a region can be invisible; if a label moves visitors, it ought to show up in the municipality that holds it. The design is simple and hard to argue with: analyse sixteen Italian sites and compare the destination’s tourism flows before and after inscription.

The result: on average, growth rates of tourism demand in the five years after inscription are not higher than growth rates in the five years before, although a number of different patterns emerge across cases. And the conclusion the authors draw is written as what it is, a direct policy implication: at least for a mature destination like Italy, there is no statistical evidence that World Heritage listing is associated with accelerating market growth rates.

The fact that distinct patterns emerge among the sixteen instances carries significance and ought not to be dismissed as a tie. This implies varying rates of expansion across the cohorts, demonstrating that the designation itself does not serve as the dividing line between them.

The test no one else has conducted

Michael Volgger and Ross Taplin, affiliated with Curtin University, tackled the issue from a different angle within the pages of the Journal of Sustainable Tourism back in 2022, marking their study as the sole piece of research in this domain incorporating random assignment. The methodological advancements they outline effectively highlight the void they managed to address: it is the first to use randomisation to produce robust causal conclusions, the first to compare national park designation with World Heritage status, and the first to scrutinise the role of advertising strategy.

The findings are divided into two parts. The positive outcome shows that national park and World Heritage declarations significantly increase the likelihood of visitation. Conversely, the subsequent point undermines the core claim of the report, revealing that the added value of declaring a World Heritage Site above declaring a national park is insignificant in a domestic tourism market.

Two qualifications the authors add are worth holding on to. Tourists’ attitudes towards protected areas significantly moderate these effects, which is to say the label works on people who already value that kind of place. And effects related to advertising strategy are negligible: it cannot be fixed with a campaign.

How large are the effects that are found

Various investigations demonstrate favorable outcomes, including methodologies executed with high rigor. Within these analyses, directionality holds less significance than overall scale.

The panel of the twenty-seven European Union member states by Didem Kutlu, Mehmet Zanbak and colleagues in Sustainability in 2024, employing the Driscoll-Kraay method, offers the most insightful analysis. Their primary conclusion highlights that UNESCO sites exert the greatest influence among all evaluated cultural variables. Furthermore, the data reveals that each additional UNESCO site leads to a 0.22% rise in tourist numbers.

On its own, that reads like a success. Set beside the next line of the same article, it changes meaning: the most crucial determinant of tourist arrivals is bed capacity, with a one per cent increase leading to a 0.66 per cent increase in arrivals. Three times as much as the label. The same table includes a result that often surprises: healthcare expenditure and political civil liberties appear with a negative impact on arrivals.

The study with the cleanest causal identification in favour of the label uses mobility big data. Yan-Yan Gao, Mengyun Fang and colleagues published in Current Issues in Tourism in 2022 an analysis using daily city-pair tourist flow intensities from Tencent migration big data, across two Chinese national holidays between 2015 and 2019, with multi-dimensional fixed effects panel models.

Their outcome: one World Heritage Site increases inbound tourist flow intensity by at least 6.7% and up to around 10%. Heterogeneity across vacation types, daily patterns throughout the break, and high-speed rail links is documented by the authors, while the impact withstands multiple robustness checks. This represents a robust quantification of a genuine phenomenon restricted to peak-demand intervals.

For Europe, Elisa Panzera, Thomas de Graaff and Henri de Groot estimated in Papers in Regional Science in 2020 a Bayesian multilevel gravity model and gave a magnitude in people: UNESCO cultural World Heritage Sites are associated with an increase of 6,000 international tourists — one site — to 60,000 — eight sites — from each European country to an average European region. Their most interesting finding is of a different order: the presence of UNESCO sites reduces the distance decay effect, because international tourists are willing to travel further if the destination has them.

The same article supplies the contrast public debate never makes: regionally or nationally defined tangible forms of heritage — local monuments, cultural landscapes, museums — play a more limited role as pull factors.

Placed side by side on a single table, the effect sizes drawn from the papers yielding positive outcomes display a pattern that remains hidden upon individual review: the narrower the analytical unit and the briefer the timeframe evaluated, the greater the magnitude of the impact seems to be.

StudyUnit and periodEstimated magnitude
Kutlu and others (2024)Country, EU-27 panel+0.22% tourists per site
Yamarik (2025)Country pair, 2000-2021, ~200 countriesPresence significant; additional site marginal
Panzera and others (2020)European region, Bayesian gravity model6,000 tourists per site; 60,000 with eight
Castillo-Manzano and others (2021)Province, 50 Spanish provinces, 2000-2019Positive, larger for the older labels
Gao and others (2022)City, two holidays a year, 2015-2019+6.7% to +10% inflow intensity
VanBlarcom and Kayahan (2011)One site, 1990-2008 series+6.2% visitors

This is no paradox: it is what one should expect. A national measurement spreads the effect across the whole territory, and a holiday measurement captures the peak rather than the annual average. When somebody cites a «double-digit increase» from the label, the first thing to ask is which unit and which time window.

Why it works in some places and not others

At least five distinct factors driving this dispersion have been pointed out by existing research, and every single one of them can be verified prior to drafting a nomination.

ConditionWhat the evidence saysWhere it was measured
Destination’s development levelWorks as a quality signal where information is scarceReview of 53 articles (2026)
Prior saturation of the destinationIn saturated destinations, net effect close to zeroReview of 53 articles (2026)
First against additionalHaving a site is significant; having another, marginalYamarik, Tourism Economics (2025)
Age of the labelFirst-generation effect: the 1980s listings, larger50 Spanish provinces (2021)
Heritage type and coastlineInland: only cultural. Coastal: only natural50 Spanish provinces (2021)
Domestic against international marketIn China, positive domestically and null internationally287 Chinese cities (2023)

The distinction between «having a site» and «having one more» was formulated by Steven Yamarik in Tourism Economics in 2025 using a structural gravity equation for close to 200 countries between 2000 and 2021. His result: the presence of a World Heritage Site in the destination nation has a positive and significant impact on international tourism. In contrast, an additional site is positive but only marginally significant. For a country that already has several, dossier number twelve is not dossier number one.

The Spanish case was examined by José Castillo-Manzano, Mercedes Castro-Nuño, Lourdes López-Valpuesta and Ángel Zarzoso in Journal of Cultural Heritage in 2021, using original panel data covering every single province from 2000 through 2019. A positive influence on both international and domestic visitor demand is uncovered when evaluating all provinces collectively, alongside two crucial caveats that should reshape any strategic approach: the earliest inscribed locations—dating back to the 1980s—generate a much stronger tourism boost, a phenomenon termed by the researchers as a «first generation effect», while coastal and interior areas show distinct divergences: cultural landmarks drive growth exclusively in inland provinces, whereas natural attractions wield drawing power solely along the coast.

The most puzzling contrast comes from Cheng Zhang, Wei Cheng and Wanli Zhang in Tourism Economics in 2023, using panel data from 287 Chinese prefecture-level cities between 2002 and 2018 with propensity score matching combined with difference-in-differences. World Heritage sites improve regional tourism significantly, but the arrival and revenue effects on inbound tourism are not significant. And there is geography within the country: they generate significant economic benefits for the eastern and western regions but not the central one. The mechanism analysis points to tourism public services substantially increasing the effects.

The most concrete figure in this whole literature, by virtue of its modesty, came from Brian VanBlarcom and Cevat Kayahan in Journal of Heritage Tourism in 2011, using Nova Scotia’s only already-established site — Lunenburg, inscribed in 1995 — to estimate what a neighbouring nomination could expect. They estimated a 6.2% increase in tourist visitors attributable to the designation, which for the candidate site meant 3,000 extra visitors a year and spending of approximately $200,000 annually in the local economy.

Data pointFigure
Econometric estimates synthesised344, from 43 studies
Effect per additional site across the EU-27+0.22% tourists
Effect of 1% more bed capacity+0.66% arrivals
Effect on Chinese national holidaysBetween +6.7% and +10%
International tourists per cultural site, average European region6,000; with eight sites, 60,000
Italian growth after the label against beforeNo higher
Added value of the label over «national park»Not significant
Lunenburg case, Nova Scotia+6.2%: 3,000 visitors and $200,000 a year

The consequence no one questions

There is one point on which the literature is unanimous and which almost never appears in the debate about visitors, and it is important not to lose sight of it when reading everything above: the 2026 systematic review documents that on the social dimension the label often triggers tensions between strict conservation standards and livelihood needs, and that those tensions result in overtourism and growing frustration among local communities.

Its concluding advice consequently focuses less on marketing and more on administration: the research establishes a foundation that encourages lawmakers to abandon the blind chase for titles and pivot toward sustainable destination management alongside fairer benefit distribution.

And a methodological note for anyone tracking this space: the paper itself notes that existing research reveals a clear shift from descriptive observations to causal econometric models and the application of big data. Consequently, upcoming studies over the next few years are bound to surpass those shaping the current debate. Treating the matter as settled would be premature.

Viewed collectively, the twelve investigations outline a designation that achieves a genuine effect, albeit one substantially more limited than the dossiers suggest. It proves most effective when acting as a basic signal — an initial landmark within a nation where travelers possess scant alternative data to rely on — whereas it diminishes entirely when a locale is already renowned and crowded. This dynamic runs counter to how proponents typically frame the case, given that municipalities capable of funding a candidacy are generally those requiring it the least. Furthermore, the single most valuable line across the entire body of research for any budgetary debate concerns bed capacity: a single euro allocated to accommodations generates three times the visitor volume of a euro spent on the paperwork.

What to do with this, in practice

• Check whether the destination is already saturated before invoking the tourism argument. The 2026 review puts the net effect close to zero in those cases, and the Italian study found no acceleration in a mature destination.

• Ask whether the site would be the country’s first or one more. The 2025 gravity equation draws the distinction clearly: having one is significant; having another, marginal.

• Compare against cheaper alternatives. The only randomised experiment found that declaring a national park produces an equivalent effect on domestic visit intention.

• Look at hotel capacity before the dossier. In the European panel, 1% more beds moves three times as many arrivals as one additional site.

• Align your expectations with the heritage classification and the region. Within Spain, the impact tends to be cultural inland and natural along the coastline, where historical designations carry more weight than recent ones.

• Budget for management, not just for the nomination. The tension between conservation and local livelihoods, alongside the issue of overtourism, stands out as the most consistent social finding in the field.

Frequently asked questions

Does the UNESCO label raise visitor numbers?

On average yes, but by little and very unevenly. The European panel gives +0.22% per additional site; the Chinese big data, between 6.7% and 10% on holidays; and the Italian municipal-level study found no acceleration in growth after inscription.

Why do the studies give such different results?

The meta-analysis of 344 estimates identified six factors explaining the dispersion: the period, the country’s development level, the heritage type, the data type, how site endowment is measured and whether robust standard errors were used.

Does submitting a nomination truly pay off?

The outcome hinges upon the initial baseline. When dealing with an overcrowded location, data indicates an impact near zero. Conversely, for a nation lacking any site entirely, the influence proves substantial. Furthermore, the 2022 trial demonstrates that establishing a national park delivers an identical outcome within the home market.

How much tourism does a site move in Europe?

The 2020 gravity model estimates around 6,000 additional international tourists for one cultural site and 60,000 with eight, from each European country to an average European region. It also finds the label reduces the decay of flow with distance.

Does it affect domestic and international tourism equally?

No. In the study of 287 Chinese cities, the label significantly improves regional tourism, but the arrival and revenue effects on inbound international tourism are not significant.

Does it matter whether the label is old or recent?

Yes. The research covering the 50 provinces of Spain highlights a «first generation effect»: registrations dating back to the 1980s exert a stronger allure for travelers than those from subsequent years.

Which labeling effect enjoys the most robust documentation?

Paradoxically, not the tourism one. The review of 53 articles consistently finds that the designation triggers tensions between conservation standards and local livelihood needs, with associated overtourism and resident frustration.

What we do not know

• What the real average effect is. The meta-analysis explains why the studies differ, but expressly declines to deliver an interpretable mean, and published ranges run from zero to double digits.

  • Where the saturation threshold lies. The 2026 review distinguishes saturated destinations from unsaturated ones without fixing the point at which the effect disappears.
  • Why the label moves domestic but not international tourists in China. The contrast is measured but not explained.
  • Whether stated visit intention translates into visits. The sole randomised experiment measures intention, and no one has replicated its methodology to track actual behaviour.
  • How much of the «first generation effect» stems from age versus location quality. The earliest inscriptions also displayed the highest quality, and the dataset reveals that these two variables intertwine.

References

1. Yang, Y., Xue, L. and Jones, T. E. «Tourism-enhancing effect of World Heritage Sites: Panacea or placebo? A meta-analysis». Annals of Tourism Research, 2019. 10.1016/j.annals.2018.12.007

2. Ribaudo, G. and Figini, P. «The Puzzle of Tourism Demand at Destinations Hosting UNESCO World Heritage Sites». Journal of Travel Research, 2017. 10.1177/0047287516643413

3. Adie, B. A., Hall, C. M. and Prayag, G. «World Heritage as a placebo brand: a comparative analysis of three sites and marketing implications». Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2018. 10.1080/09669582.2017.1359277

4. Volgger, M. and Taplin, R. «The impact of national park and UNESCO world heritage site designations on visit intentions: evidence from a randomised experiment». Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2022. 10.1080/09669582.2022.2144870

5. Castillo-Manzano, J. I., Castro-Nuño, M., López-Valpuesta, L. and Zarzoso, Á. «Assessing the tourism attractiveness of World Heritage Sites: The case of Spain». Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2021. 10.1016/j.culher.2020.12.005

6. Gao, Y.-Y., Fang, M. and others. «World Heritage Site inscription and city tourism attractiveness on national holidays: new evidence with migration big data from China». Current Issues in Tourism, 2022. 10.1080/13683500.2022.2073203

7. Panzera, E., de Graaff, T. and de Groot, H. «European cultural heritage and tourism flows: The magnetic role of superstar World Heritage Sites». Papers in Regional Science, 2020. 10.1111/pirs.12562

8. Kutlu, D., Zanbak, M. and others. «The Influence of World Heritage Sites on Tourism Dynamics in the EU 27 Nations». Sustainability, 2024. 10.3390/su16209090

9. Yamarik, S. «The effects of world heritage sites on bilateral tourism demand». Tourism Economics, 2025. 10.1177/13548166251348951

10. Zhang, C., Cheng, W. and Zhang, W. «Does World Heritage inscription promote regional tourism? Evidence from China». Tourism Economics, 2023. 10.1177/13548166221075453

11. VanBlarcom, B. and Kayahan, C. «Assessing the economic impact of a UNESCO World Heritage designation». Journal of Heritage Tourism, 2011. 10.1080/1743873x.2011.561858

12. Hạnh, M. T., Nguyen, H. and others. «The impact of world heritage inscription on tourism: A systematic review of economic, social, and governance dimensions». Multidisciplinary Reviews, 2026. Low-quartile journal. 10.31893/multirev.2026608

This article summarises peer-reviewed scientific literature on the effect of World Heritage listing on tourism demand, flagging in the text the low-quartile publication included. The figures correspond to the countries and periods studied and are not extrapolable to any destination. It is not tourism policy advice, nor an assessment of any nomination.

By Lily Chang

You May Also Like